The Complete Idiot's Guide

Growing Your Business With Google
By Dave Taylor

Crafting the Ideal Business Blog Comment Strategy

After working in the computer industry for decades, I'm used to the most seemingly benign topic exploding into a passionate - and sometimes even vitriolic - debate, from which editor you use to what operating system, programming language to which HTML mark-up standard you work towards.

In the blogging world, surprisingly, the big debate isn't about what blogging tool to use, and it's not about design or layout. It's not really even about whether to include advertising or not, as far as I can tell. The two big hot-buttons are about RSS feeds, whether to have a "full feed" or a "partial feed", and about your blog comment policy.

In this article, I'm going to talk about the latter topic, and I promise I'll address RSS feeds in a different piece (and at length in my Blogging 101 workshop at Blog Business Summit).

First off, let me state categorically that I believe it's critical that all business blogs allow comments to be added by readers. Without it, you miss out on the ability to establish a dialog and have only made the smallest step from a static Web site. It's still The Voice of The Company, and visitors still have no ability to add their perspective or response, it's just a different tool in play.

Some business blogs don't allow comments, notably Clip 'n Seal News, but they're the rare exception because much of the most interesting content comes from the comments, not the original article. After all, even the best writer can only represent one primary point of view, so how do you learn about other perspectives if not from the addition of material from people who disagree?

The debate, however, isn't about whether or not to allow comments. Just about every business blogger I know recommends enabling comments as a best practice, in fact.

The debate is about whether to edit, censor, screen or modify comments. Indeed, the very language of the debate informs us of the passion behind the scenes: "censor" is only loosely applicable in this situation, and while people argue "freedom of the press" and other so-called Constitutional arguments, they don't actually apply to a private publication such as a blog, with no obligation or legal requirement to represent all perspectives and publish the views of all readers.

This question is nonetheless critical to consider before you launch your own business blog, however: are you going to leave all comments pristine, untouched, and let obscenities, fallacious arguments, racism, sexism, and other offensive writing stand or fall on its own merits, or are you going to edit and control your content?

In fact, there are more nuances to this discussion anyway, because I don't know any serious blogger who allows every comment to stand, because their site would promptly be overrun by spammers adding nonsensical comments about Viagra and gambling sites or subverted into a discussion venue for lowlifes or criminals.

So in fact, there's a continuum at work here, a scale where on one end people allow everything, don't blacklist, don't filter spam, don't remove duplicate comments, don't touch anything, and at the other end of the scale where they tightly edit and screen all comments, only allowing those that agree or represent specific alternative viewpoints. Probably, you'd be hard pressed to find an example on either end of this comment permissibility continuum, because we're all somewhere in the middle.

This helps illuminate the discussion because it helps clarify that when bloggers say "I leave all comments" they really mean "I leave all relevant, on-topic comments." They're on that continuum. And when other bloggers say "I control the comments on my site and sometimes reject comments" they too are on that continuum.

My counsel on the subject is closer to the latter than the former view, perhaps surprisingly. I'm a strong advocate of dissenting opinions and a healthy debate, and I am okay - perhaps a bit begrudgingly - if subsequent comments pick apart an argument of my own and make me look less than omniscient (just don't tell my kids, okay?)

I believe, however, that if a blog has a recognizable business sponsor or individual shepherd, then everything on the blog has an implied ownership, a brand identity, of that owner.

If I were to read a Nike blog, for example, and read ongoing discussion of how sweatshops were actually good for Southeast Asian economies, I'd take that as a viewpoint that Nike tacitly endorsed by retaining the entries on its site. A follow-on from someone at Nike saying "we don't agree at all." just wouldn't cut it. A discussion of this nature would far more appropriately belong on a separate forum not run or paid for by Nike.

And maybe that's where the proverbial rubber hits the road here: business blogs are an expense paid by the marketing, customer service, or public relations arm of a company. In that light, I believe it's quite reasonable for the company to constantly ask "Is the addition of this content going to make us a more successful company? Are we going to sell more stuff? Attract more customers? Appeal to investors?" WIthout those questions, a business blog is a corporate initiative gone horribly awry, and will quickly morph into something that is not in the best interest of the company and a disservice to its employees and shareholders.

I have always counseled companies to consider their business blog an interactive magazine that they're publishing and managing for the benefit of their customers, market segment, and shareholders. This makes it easy to decide whether someone calling your blogger, or CEO, a jerk is submitting a comment worth retaining.

If you don't agree, ask this question: when you read the Letters to the Editor at a publication like Newsweek, The Wall Street Journal or The New Republic, do you seriously think that they've just pulled in the first four or five letters received, and reproduced them unedited? Of course not.

The same holds true for business blogs. Personal blogs live at almost all possible points along the comment permissibility continuum, but business blogs need to be more controlled, more limited, and more tightly edited so as to ensure that they serve the greatest possible value for the company.

Category: Blogging News   (Article #4366)

the major problem with most of small business blogs is that they take dissenting opinions personally and react accordingly.

Posted by: meinhard at December 9, 2006 1:33 AM

I do have a comment, now that you mention it!

Remember personal info?

Please note that I will never send you any unsolicited email or communication. Ever. I hate it just as much as you do.

While I'm at it, please note that by submitting a question or comment you're agreeing to my terms of service, which are: you relinquish any subsequent rights of ownership to your material by submitting it on this site.

Growing Your Business with Google
Buy The Book!

Site Contents
Blogging News
Google Q&A
Growing Your Business
Inside The Book
Reviews and Testimonials
Search Engine News
Updates for Readers
Buy the book!
About Dave Taylor


Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Get Updates via Email!
sent monthly


Archives by Category
Blogging News
New Wordpress release, a must-have for security and features
Google Friends Newsletter for April, 2006
What's your opinion of these blogs?
Crafting the Ideal Business Blog Comment Strategy
Come up to speed on Business Blogging @ The Blog Business Summit

Google Q&A
AdSense moving to video ads?
Should I integrate AdSense in my site design?
Does domain name affect search engine ranking?
Why don't I rank highly for all relevant searches?
Stuck in the Google sandbox or delisted?
Coming soon: Google Shopping?
Can I add new Web sites to my Google AdSense account?
How to read Google AdSense reports
Can I have AdSense and other Ads on my site simultaneously?
Does AdSense for Search pay less than AdSense for Content?
How do I target AdWords to specific Web sites?
Can DNS changes affect your Search Engine Results Placement?
Google AdSense adds "Advertise on this site"?
Exactly what does Google PageRank mean?
Does Googlebot visit more often because of my blog?
How do I optimize my Web site for a specific key word?
How much do I need to bid on Google AdWords for keywords?
Why Text Links are Better than Graphic Links
Does Google Consider My Site a Link Farm?
What's New at Google?
Paid for SEO but I still have PageRank 0?

Growing Your Business
Welcome, Entrepreneur!
Join me in Chicago for the System Seminar and learn even more about Internet marketing
Learn about business writing with a free ebook
Announcing the Growing Your Business with Google workshop!
How to Get Started with Google AdSense
How quickly should companies respond to customer email?
LinkedIn + BusinessWeek poll = connection spam?
Tips for getting more traffic to your blog
Search Engine Friendly, or Easy Navigation?
The Table of Contents

Inside The Book
Foreword, by Guy Kawasaki
Introduction to the Book
Increasing Your Business Visibility (chapter 1)
The Benefits of Increasing Your Visibility (Chapter 2)
What Is Google Anyway? (Chapter 3)
Learning about Google Search (Chapter 4)
Disassembling the Google Search Engine (Chapter 5)
What's Your Core Business? (Chapter 6)
Living in an Online World (Chapter 7)
Your Business Website (Chapter 8)
Assessing Your Competitors (Chapter 9)
Keeping Track of Customers (Chapter 10)
The Basics of Building A Good Business Site (Chapter 11)
Developing Online and Offline Content (Chapter 12)
Stretching Your Marketing Dollars (Chapter 13)
Secrets of the Online Marketing Masters (Chapter 14)
Content, Content, Content! (Chapter 15)
Becoming a More Popular Site (Chapter 16)
Becoming an Online Expert (Chapter 17)
Advertising Your Business with Google AdWords (Chapter 18)
Making Money with Google AdSense (Chapter 19)
The Advantages of Affiliate Programs (Chapter 20)
Avoiding Dumb Online Promotional Mistakes (Chapter 21)
Growing and Expanding Your Content (Chapter 22)
The Future of Findability (Chapter 23)

Reviews and Testimonials
Falesa Adkins says...
Mark McGuinness says...
Holli says...
NetworkWorld's James Gaskin says...
Craig Swanson says...
Andrew Sikorski says...
David Teten says...
Dan Janal says...
Robin Stavisky says...
Skip Uldriks says...
Don Bell says...
Vincent Wright says...
Andrew Goodman says...
Denise O'Berry says...
Thomas Duff Says...
Kevin Farnham says...
David Karlins says...
Tom Peters says...
Janet Attard says...
Jim Sterne says...
Gregg Stebben says...
Nick Usborne says...
Robert Scoble says...
Chris Pirillo says...
Rajesh Setty says...
Brad Fallon says...
Bill French says...
Debbie Weil says...
Andy Mindel says...
Andrew Goodman says...
Initial "Growing Your Business with Google" Press Release

Search Engine News
Google Friends Newsletter, Sept 2008
Bill Gates: The Age of Software-Powered Communications
Google Friends Newsletter - April 2007
Beta announcement of Google AdSense Referrals
Enabling Secure Anywhere Access in a Connected World
Google Friends Newsletter
Google Launches Hosted Communications Services
AdWords now has fraud analysis accessible to advertisers
Google doesn't support click fraud. But isn't that obvious?
Welcome to Google's online payment system, Google Checkout
Google now offers Ad Scheduling for AdWords
AdSense click fraud done by robots?
AdSense: Google's Hidden Payroll
Fun new Google service: Movie info
Google agrees to pay $90 mln in click fraud suit
Latest news from Google: Google Friends Newsletter
Nofollow: Another salvo in the Spam Wars
Google Toolbar Gets Personal
Yahoo Search redesign scheduled?
Note from the Google AdSense Team
What's the future of Pay Per Click (PPC) advertising?
New Google AdWords Keyword System Released

Updates for Readers
Blogging for Search Engine Results
Why does advertising site Chitika audit commission payments?
Google Adsense Update: Section Targeting
Understanding "link:" results (book errata)

Join the List!
Join my author info mailing list, where you'll learn about my upcoming books, speaking gigs, and more!

Book Links
Powered by
Movable Type

sitemap | link to us!